Engineering purpose: Raise the bar for certain especially important decisions.
How it works:
- Constitutional amendments: 2/3 of both houses + 3/4 of states
- Veto override: 2/3 of both houses
- Treaty ratification: 2/3 of Senate
- Impeachment: 2/3 of Senate (after House majority)
Why this promotes good ideas:
- Preventing rash changes: Easy to pass laws with 51%, but fundamental changes need broad consensus
- Forcing deliberation: Achieving 2/3 or 3/4 requires extensive coalition-building and compromise
- Stability: System can't be easily changed by temporary majorities
- Strong signal: If 2/3 agree, likely a genuine consensus not partisan victory
Modern engineering analog: Critical safety systems require multiple confirmations before activation (nuclear weapons, emergency shutdowns). High-consequence actions need high certainty.
What the Founders would add today: Different supermajority thresholds for different types of decisions based on reversibility and impact; emergency procedures with post-hoc review; sunset provisions for major legislation.
Comments (0)
You don't have permission to comment on this page.