An ID system would harm privacy.

Reasons to agree

 

 

Reasons to disagree

1. If we don't have borders we don't really have a country.
2. If we don't have any way to distinguish citizens from non-citizens, that we really don't have a country.

 

Related

1. Obama is wrong on immigration.
2. Laws strong enough to discourage employing illegal aliens would be extreme.
3. An ID system for guest workers would cost too much.
4. It is extreme to not let people stay in America who broke the law to get here.
5. The way we treat illegal immigrants is the way they treated Anne Frank.
6. People won't have enough money to self-deport.